Brasilmagic\’s Weblog

Venting to the World

Should you tell your boyfriend you want to get married?

Hmm…I can see some feminists saying I am telling women to be manipulative. I can see people comparing my advice to “The Rules”. Still, I am not the kind of woman who thinks women have to bend over backwards to please men, and I certainly am for women speaking their mind.

However, from living for several decades and seeing women get into all sorts of trouble with the whole proposal/engagement/marriage thing, I have a tiny suspicion: the more you show a man you want to get married (to him, hopefully), the less he will want it. It is sooo biological. We cannot deny evolution, and we cannot deny that men are usually less eager to get married. All those fears about losing their freedom, being accountable, being responsible, not being able to sleep with other women (unless they become rich and famous like David Letterman:)), etc, come into play. So we often hear more stories about men postponing marriage or not wanting to talk about it than women (read my post about commitment phobia from 2008).

Here is the deal: men used to be hunters. They like challenges, and they quickly lose interest in a woman who is too easy a catch. That’s why some of them don’t call after they had sex with you on that one night stand. You can be the most beautiful woman with model looks, have the brain of an Einstein and the kindness of Mother Theresa, but if you pressure him to get married, or indicate that you badlweddingy want to get married (even after 2 years of dating), he will drag his feet.

Why? Because he wants it to be HIS IDEA. He wants to have to convince you!

What if many years go by, you never say anything, and he still doesn’t ask you to marry him? In that case dear, he really doesn’t want to get married, unless he came from a planet where there is no marriage. You then may want to cut your losses and move on to greener pastures, or accept having a relationship without marriage if you love him so much that you can’t live without him (and without making you bitter in the process).

Last Sunday I read an interesting article in the “Love Me” section of the Washington Post. This woman was 32 and divorced. She met this really nice guy, and she told him she did not want to get married again; that she thougt it was an opressive institution for women (??, are we back in the 70’s?). Bingo. That did it. Her BF of course did not take long to propose and asked her to marry him with this original line: “Do you want to grow extremely old with me”? I loved it.

So girls…if the subject of marriage comes up (YOU did not start it!) and your BF asks your opinion, how about saying you are not thinking of marriage? Do you feel that is acting? That it goes against your principles? That you just cannot lie to him? In that case, how about saying: “I will consider getting married when I find the right person”. That does not make you a manipulator or a liar, and might well make him want to become that right person.

And you shouldn’t say: “I am breaking up with you because you don’t want to get married”. He might try to get you back and even propose, but it will still not be his idea, not something he REALLY wants. Basically he is marrying you so he doesn’t lose the relationship entirely, and the consequences are known to many people: a not so committed husband.

So..don’t ooh and ahh when you see an engagement ring ad, when you walk by a wedding dress in a window display or try to have “the talk” with him. He needs to want it too. Badly.

So what do you guys and gals think of this approach? Can we really keep our mouths shut about something so important to us? Is this approach too fake and manipulative, or wise?PS: Now, another little story which disproves this theory (but it can backfire): a woman had just been through a painful break up with a commitment phobic guy. She was tired of dating guys who would not commit. She went to a bar one day not expecting to meet anyone special. A nice guy sat next to her and started a conversation. At a certain point, he asked her: “why are you here alone”? And she said: “because I want to find a guy who will marry me, have 2 kids, the SUV and the single family home”. Did the guy run away? No, he married her. Yes, those things can also happen, so you never know.


November 12, 2009 - Posted by | Relationships


  1. I disagree. What you’re advocating is game-playing, and while that may have short term benefits, it creates a less than honest atmosphere that has no place in a relationship between two mature adults. If a woman wants to get married, she should simply ask the man if he wants to marry her. If he says, yes, great. If he says, no, the woman should find another man – one who does want to get married. People try to make the process complicated, but it’s pretty straight-forward if one takes control.

    I am engaged. When I started dating my fiance, I told him directly, “When I was younger, all I wanted from men was sex. But now I’m at the stage where I’m ready for marriage. I don’t think it should take years to decide whether or not we’re right for each other, so if we don’t know we want to be married after a year or so, we should probably part ways and find other people.”

    After a year and a half, we weren’t sure, so we broke up. I spent the next year or so having a good time meeting other men, having sex, and having adventures. I even got a job in a new city. But then, my fiance came back into my life and this time we were sure. Ever since, neither he nor I have experienced much hesitation, and certainly no resentment or unhappiness about it. He followed me to my current city, and he’s actually more excited about the wedding day than I am.

    There are gobs of men out there who want to get married. Often they are insecure and looking for a strong woman to tell them, “I’m looking for a man to love and support, one who will do the same for me. I will tolerate nothing less.” A man who is awkward and non-committal towards the idea of marriage is most likely not a good marriage match in the first place. Women who want to get married should not waste a minute of their time with those men, not when there are so many men out who are really craving a stable, life-long relationship.

    Comment by Sig | November 29, 2009 | Reply

  2. Sig, I hear you. I am writing in an ironic way. Of course the best way is to be upfront about your needs, and have a sincere and honest communication. I am brainstorming about what would happen if a woman does reverse psychology and tells the guy she is not interested in marriage, does that make him more interested (and less fearful)? I saw this article on the Washington Post in the “In love” section that brought that idea up.

    Comment by Brasilmagic | December 7, 2009 | Reply

  3. I agree with the article, it’s surprising what a little psychology could do… I have been in several relationships and none have been fulfilling, neither is my current relationship. With men I have learned that you often have to outsmart them and yes not mentioning certain things or being indifferent do make them react faster, otherwise they will drag their feet and never commit. It’s how majority of men are wired. I am still hoping to find the right man for me.

    Comment by Micaela | December 18, 2009 | Reply

  4. Gosh… I’m a guy and it’s so true that I agree with you completely.

    Comment by Thomas | May 13, 2010 | Reply

  5. damnit i wish i i read this before meeting my guy..we are both divorced but i told him i am ready to settle down and looking for someone along the same lines..but he told me he is too scared to get married again! 😦 😦

    Comment by afia | July 15, 2011 | Reply

  6. i ve been with my guy for years now and he has always being cheating on me….Sorry and wishing me A happy bday seems the hardest word for him to say……. i had a daughter before meeting him and now my baby’s wants me back and has proposed to me but my problem is i don’nt know how to tell my bf about. im not hapy with him anymore pls help

    Comment by Michelle | August 19, 2012 | Reply

  7. 6.i ve been with my guy for years now and he has always being cheating on me….Sorry and wishing me A happy bday seems the hardest word for him to say……. i had a daughter before meeting him and now my baby’s dad wants me back and has proposed to me but my problem is i don’nt know how to tell my bf about. im not hapy with him anymore pls help

    Comment by Michelle | August 19, 2012 | Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: